What Is a Good Cap Rate? A Guide for Real Estate Investors
- Ryan McDowell
- 7 hours ago
- 16 min read
Reading Time 8 min | Good for: Novice (A), Informed (B)
TL;DR: Your Quick Guide to a Good Cap Rate
There is no single "good" cap rate. A good cap rate is one that accurately reflects the risk and potential return of a specific property, in a specific market, at a specific point in time. It's not a magic number.
Cap rates and risk have an inverse relationship. Low cap rates (e.g., 4-6%) typically signal lower risk, higher-value properties. High cap rates (e.g., 8%+) suggest higher risk but offer the potential for greater returns.
Context is everything. A 5% cap rate might be excellent for a new multifamily building in Miami but a major red flag for an older retail center in a tertiary market. You must analyze the property type, location, and asset quality.
A cap rate is only as reliable as its inputs. Always scrutinize the Net Operating Income (NOI). A sponsor using inflated, pro-forma numbers can make a bad deal look good on paper. Always verify the numbers with trailing financials.
Let's get straight to it. When investors ask, "What is a good cap rate?", they're looking for a simple answer to a complex question. The truth is, there is no single magic number. Instead, think of it as a financial seesaw: a low cap rate often points to a high-value, lower-risk property in a hot market, while a high cap rate signals a shot at higher returns, but with significantly more risk attached.
What a Good Cap Rate Really Tells You
For any seasoned investor, the capitalization (cap) rate is one of the first metrics they look at to size up a commercial real estate deal. It’s a quick-and-dirty way to gauge a property's potential unlevered annual return, making it incredibly useful for comparing different opportunities on an apples-to-apples basis.
But the idea of a universal "good" cap rate just doesn't hold up in the real world. Why? Because the metric is entirely dependent on context. A good rate is simply one that correctly prices the risk you're taking on for the potential reward, given the specific property, its market, and the current economic climate.
The Risk and Return Seesaw
The core concept to grasp is the inverse relationship between cap rates and risk. When investors are willing to pay more for every dollar of Net Operating Income (NOI), the cap rate goes down. This signals their confidence in the asset’s stability and future growth potential. It's a crowded trade, and you're paying a premium for safety.
Low Cap Rates (e.g., 4-6%): You'll find these in high-demand, low-risk assets. Think of a brand-new multifamily building in a gateway city like Miami or an industrial warehouse locked into a long-term lease with an Amazon-level tenant. These are core, stabilized assets ideal for capital preservation.
High Cap Rates (e.g., 8-10%+): These are tied to assets with more "hair" on them. We're talking about a value-add retail center where several leases are about to expire, or an older office building that needs a serious cash injection for updates. The risk is higher, but so is the potential payoff if an experienced sponsor executes their business plan.
To help you visualize this spectrum, here’s a quick breakdown of what different cap rate ranges typically signify in the market.
Cap Rate at a Glance: A Spectrum of Risk and Return
Cap Rate Range | Associated Risk Level | Typical Property Profile |
|---|---|---|
Below 5% | Very Low | Prime location, new construction, credit-worthy tenants, long-term leases (e.g., Class A office in a CBD). |
5% - 7% | Low to Moderate | Stable, well-maintained property in a strong secondary market with good occupancy and reliable cash flow. |
7% - 9% | Moderate to High | Value-add opportunities, properties in emerging markets, or assets with some deferred maintenance or leasing challenges. |
10%+ | High | Opportunistic plays, properties requiring significant repositioning, or located in tertiary markets with uncertain demand. |
As the table shows, there's no "bad" cap rate—just a rate that might not align with your personal risk tolerance or investment strategy. Historically, the sweet spot for most commercial real estate cap rates has hovered between 5% and 10%, shifting with property types and market dynamics. This range is a solid benchmark, showing how investors demand different premiums for the risks associated with different assets.
Of course, to really use this metric effectively, you need to know how the sausage is made. For anyone looking to nail down the fundamentals, we lay it all out in our guide on how to calculate cap rate for real estate. Mastering that calculation is the first step to making smarter, more confident investment decisions.
The Three Levers That Shape Your Cap Rate
If you want to know if a cap rate is truly “good,” you have to look past the single number. It's really about pulling three fundamental levers that determine a property's value: the property type, its geographic location, and the quality of the physical asset.
These factors all work together to define a deal’s risk profile—and the return investors will demand for taking on that risk. A 5% cap rate might be a fantastic deal for a shiny new apartment building in Miami, but it would be a huge red flag for an old, tired retail strip in a small town. Understanding how these levers move is the difference between spotting a genuine opportunity and falling for a deal that only looks good on paper.
Lever 1: Property Type
Not all real estate is created equal. The built-in risk and stability of an asset class have a huge impact on its typical cap rate. Properties with consistent, predictable demand usually have lower, more compressed cap rates because investors will pay a premium for that reliable cash flow.
Stable Assets (Lower Cap Rates): Think multifamily and industrial warehouses. People always need a place to live, and the e-commerce boom has created what feels like endless demand for logistics space. This durability means lower perceived risk.
Volatile Assets (Higher Cap Rates): On the flip side, properties like hotels or specialized retail can be much more sensitive to the swings of the economy. Their income is less predictable, so investors demand a higher cap rate to make up for the extra uncertainty.
Lever 2: Geographic Location
Real estate is a local game, first and foremost. Geography is a massive driver of value and risk. The market an asset is in will dictate its potential for rent growth, the quality of tenant demand, and its long-term appreciation. This is exactly why you'll see completely different cap rates for two identical buildings in different cities.
A property's cap rate is fundamentally a reflection of its place in the world. Investors aren't just buying bricks and mortar; they're buying into a local economy, its growth prospects, and its demographic trends.
Markets are generally broken down into tiers:
Primary Markets (e.g., New York, Los Angeles): These are the major gateway cities with diverse economies and tons of buyers and sellers. They're seen as safe havens, which pushes cap rates down significantly.
Secondary Markets (e.g., Nashville, Austin): These are hot, growing cities with strong fundamentals. They often offer a great mix of stability and growth potential, leading to slightly higher cap rates than the primary markets.
Tertiary Markets (Smaller towns): These markets are less diverse economically and have smaller populations, making them riskier. Investors need a much higher cap rate to justify putting their capital to work here.
This montage helps visualize how different asset types and locations come together to influence typical cap rate ranges.
The takeaway here is that an asset’s environment—from a bustling downtown core to a quiet suburban street—directly shapes what investors expect to earn.
Lever 3: Asset Quality and Class
Finally, the physical condition and positioning of the building itself play a huge role. In the industry, we sort buildings by class:
Class A: These are the best of the best—new, high-quality buildings in prime locations with top-tier amenities and tenants with strong credit. They represent the lowest risk and, you guessed it, have the lowest cap rates.
Class B: A solid middle ground. These are well-kept but slightly older buildings in good locations. They offer a nice balance of reliable cash flow with some potential for value-add improvements down the road.
Class C: The oldest properties, often in less desirable areas, that usually need a good bit of work. These carry the highest risk and therefore come with the highest cap rates.
By pulling these three levers—property type, location, and asset quality—you can deconstruct any deal and get the real story behind the number. For a deeper dive into the mechanics, check out our complete guide to the [cap rate formula for real estate](https://www.stiltsvillecapital.com/post/cap-rate-formula-real-estate-a-complete-guide-for-investors).
How Economic Cycles Reshape a Good Cap Rate
A cap rate isn't some static number etched in stone. Think of it more like a living, breathing metric that moves in sync with the broader economy. What you might call a “good” cap rate is constantly being redefined by big-picture macroeconomic forces, with interest rates acting as the main conductor of this orchestra.
If you want to underwrite deals with confidence in any market, you have to get a feel for this dynamic.
The connection between the cost of capital and real estate yields is direct and powerful. When central banks hike interest rates to cool down inflation, the cost of debt to acquire a property goes up. It's a simple chain reaction: investors start demanding higher returns—and therefore higher cap rates—to justify taking on more expensive debt.
It’s not just about borrowing costs, either. Rising interest rates make "safer" investments like government bonds look more appealing. If an investor can lock in a 5% return on a Treasury bond with virtually zero risk, they're going to demand a much bigger premium for the hassle and illiquidity that comes with owning a physical building. This flight to safety naturally pushes property cap rates upward just to stay competitive.
The Impact of Interest Rates and Inflation
The last two decades tell this story perfectly. From around 2000 to 2020, we watched cap rates generally trend downward, mirroring the fall of global risk-free rates. It was a low-interest-rate world that encouraged a flood of capital into real estate, compressing cap rates to below 5% in many major cities.
But the script has flipped since 2022. A dramatic spike in interest rates has sent cap rates climbing again, triggering a major repricing of commercial real estate. Take the U.S. office sector—according to CBRE, cap rates there climbed from 6.8% in mid-2022 to an estimated 8.0% by early 2024. This reflects both the tighter lending environment and shakier tenant demand.
For the Astute Investor: A 'good' cap rate from two years ago might look deeply unattractive today. The key is not to anchor your expectations to past market conditions but to underwrite based on the current cost of capital and forward-looking economic indicators.
Why This Matters for Your Strategy
Getting a handle on this cycle is absolutely crucial. Let's say an investor buys a property at a 5.5% cap rate when interest rates are at rock bottom. If rates suddenly rise and the market-clearing cap rate for similar buildings widens to 7%, they could see their property's value take a serious hit.
This is exactly why a disciplined underwriting process is non-negotiable. Stress-testing a deal's sensitivity to interest rate swings should be a core part of any risk assessment. By learning to anticipate these macroeconomic shifts, you can position your portfolio to not only weather economic storms but also to pounce on the unique opportunities that always pop up when markets get dislocated.
Benchmarking Cap Rates Across Property Types
To really get a feel for what makes a cap rate “good,” we have to step away from the theory and look at what’s happening in the real world. A cap rate isn’t some universal number; it shifts dramatically depending on the type of property you’re looking at.
Every asset class has its own unique story—its own risk profile, demand drivers, and potential for growth. All of these factors get boiled down into its typical cap rate range.
Knowing these benchmarks is non-negotiable for an investor. It’s the framework you use to size up a deal, letting you see almost instantly if a property is priced in line with the market, overvalued, or maybe, just maybe, an overlooked bargain. This context helps you ask the right questions and decide if the return on the table is worth the risk you’re taking on.
Why Multifamily and Industrial Command a Premium
You'll quickly notice some property types consistently trade at lower cap rates. There’s a good reason for that. They're often considered the bedrock of a solid commercial real estate portfolio.
Multifamily: Let’s face it, people always need a place to live. That simple fact makes residential properties incredibly resilient, holding up well even when the economy gets rocky. This predictable demand creates a steady, reliable cash flow that investors love. They're often willing to pay a premium—accepting a lower initial yield—for that peace of mind.
Industrial & Logistics: The e-commerce boom has completely reshaped the landscape. The demand for warehouses, distribution centers, and logistics hubs has been off the charts. Throw in long-term leases with credit-worthy tenants like major retailers, and you’ve got an asset class that feels incredibly safe. This has made industrial a hot ticket for big-time institutional investors, pushing cap rates down.
The Hunt for Higher Yield in Office and Retail
On the flip side, some asset classes have to offer a bigger slice of the pie to get investors interested, and that’s a direct reflection of their current challenges.
Office: The massive shift to remote and hybrid work has thrown a wrench into the traditional office market. With more empty desks and uncertainty about future demand, investors are understandably cautious. To compensate for the risk of finding and keeping tenants, they demand a higher return.
Retail: It's a tale of two cities in retail. Well-located, grocery-anchored neighborhood centers are doing just fine. But other parts of the retail world are feeling the heat from e-commerce. Properties with weaker tenants or in less-than-ideal locations are seen as riskier, and that risk gets priced right into a higher cap rate.
The numbers back this up. A Q1 2024 report from CBRE showed retail properties had some of the highest cap rates, often pushing past 7.5%. Meanwhile, the more stable multifamily assets were comfortably trading in the 5.0% to 5.5% range.
This split perfectly illustrates how market trends and sector-specific realities shape what investors are willing to pay. To see a deeper dive, you can learn more about how sector nuances determine cap rate attractiveness.
Typical Cap Rate Ranges by Commercial Property Type
This table illustrates the typical cap rate ranges for various commercial real estate sectors, reflecting their unique risk and return profiles in the current market (as of Q1 2024, per CBRE data).
Property Type | Typical Cap Rate Range | Key Influencing Factors |
|---|---|---|
Multifamily | 5.0% - 5.5% | Consistent tenant demand, economic resilience, location quality |
Industrial | 5.0% - 6.5% | E-commerce growth, lease duration, tenant creditworthiness |
Office | 7.5% - 8.5% | Remote work trends, vacancy rates, building class (A, B, C) |
Retail | 7.0% - 8.0% | Tenant mix, anchor tenant strength, consumer spending habits |
Hospitality | 8.0% - 9.5% | Travel and tourism trends, location, brand affiliation |
As you can see, the definition of a "good" cap rate is all about context. A 5.25% cap rate might be an incredible deal for a Class A apartment building in a prime location, but it would be far too low for an older hotel in a secondary market. Understanding these ranges is the first step toward making smarter, more informed investment decisions.
Don’t Get Fooled by a Pretty Cap Rate: Investor Checklist
Here's a piece of advice that separates seasoned investors from the rest: a cap rate is only as reliable as the Net Operating Income (NOI) used to calculate it. It’s easy to get excited by a high cap rate, but that number can be dangerously misleading if it's built on a shaky foundation of wishful thinking and incomplete financials.
That headline number is just the first page of the book, not the whole story. A smart investor knows to look past the glossy pro-forma and really dig into the assumptions behind the NOI figure. Is that income number based on what the property actually collected, or what someone hopes it could collect? Are all the operating expenses—every single one—accounted for realistically? The quality of your cap rate is directly tied to the quality of the numbers behind it.
An attractive cap rate based on flawed assumptions isn't an opportunity; it's a trap. True diligence means pressure-testing the NOI to make sure it reflects the property's real, sustainable cash flow.
This is where disciplined underwriting makes all the difference. Before you take any cap rate at face value, you have to get your hands dirty and dig into the details. This isn't about being negative; it's about being smart and protecting your capital from risks you can easily see coming. A quick glance just won't cut it.
Questions You Absolutely Must Ask a Sponsor Before Trusting a Cap Rate
To help you peel back the layers, think of this as your pre-flight checklist before pulling the trigger on a deal. Asking these questions will help you figure out how solid an asset's cash flow truly is.
Is the Rental Income Real? The first thing you should ask for is a trailing 12-month (T-12) financial statement. This shows you what was actually collected. Compare this to the pro-forma or "potential" income the seller is showing you. If there's a big gap, that's a red flag waving right in your face—it could signal problems with vacancies or collecting rent.
What's the Real Story on Property Taxes? Property taxes are often the single biggest expense. Crucially, you must find out if the sponsor’s tax number is based on the current assessed value or a realistic, projected value after the sale. A post-sale reassessment could send your tax bill soaring, and you need that modeled upfront.
Where are the Reserves for Capital Expenditures (CapEx)? Is money being set aside for the inevitable—like a new roof, a parking lot repaving, or an HVAC system on its last legs? A pro-forma that conveniently ignores these future capital expenditures is showing you an inflated, unrealistic NOI.
Are the Management Fees Realistic? If the current owner is managing the property themselves, they might not be including a standard management fee in the expenses. Make sure a market-rate fee, which is typically 3-5% of the gross revenue, is factored in. It’s the only way to get a true picture of the property's profitability.
What are the In-Place vs. Market Rents? Ask for a detailed rent roll. If the current rents are significantly below market, that's a potential value-add opportunity. If they are at or above market, there is little room for organic income growth and potentially higher risk of vacancy on lease expiration.
By running through this checklist, you stop being a passive observer and start actively verifying the deal's integrity. This deeper dive is what separates a great investment from one that just looks good on paper.
Putting It All Together: Your Framework for Evaluating Deals
So, let's tie this all together. If there's one thing to take away from this guide, it's this: there’s no magic number for a "good" cap rate. It’s a deeply personal metric that has everything to do with your unique investment strategy.
Are you focused on preserving capital, generating a steady stream of income, or chasing aggressive growth? The right cap rate is simply the one that correctly prices the risk you're willing to take for the reward you're after. The goal is to stop looking at it as a single data point and start using it as part of a more holistic evaluation framework.
How to Contextualize the Cap Rate
To really analyze an offering with confidence, you need to filter the cap rate through three critical lenses. Think of it as a quick gut check.
Asset Class: Is this a stable, high-demand property like a multifamily apartment complex, or something more volatile like a hotel that's sensitive to economic swings?
Market Dynamics: Are we looking at a prime gateway city where yields are naturally tight, or a smaller, tertiary market where you’d expect a higher return to compensate for the added risk?
Economic Climate: How do today’s interest rates and inflation forecasts make this deal look compared to other places you could put your money?
When you layer these factors, you can start to see if a property’s risk-return profile truly lines up with your long-term goals. This structured approach helps you move past the headline number and ask sponsors sharper, more insightful questions.
A good cap rate doesn't just tell you about a property's income today. It reflects your confidence in its future performance, its strength within the market, and its ability to withstand whatever headwinds come its way.
Ultimately, this framework turns the cap rate from a simple metric into a powerful diagnostic tool. Getting a handle on these nuances is essential, especially when you consider the various types of investment risk in real estate. Armed with this guide, you’re in a much better position to build a resilient, high-performing portfolio as part of a long-term wealth strategy.
Diving Deeper: Your Cap Rate Questions Answered
Alright, let's tackle some of the common questions that pop up when investors start using cap rates in the real world. Think of this as the practical part of the conversation, where we move from theory to how these numbers actually play out.
What’s a "Good" Cap Rate for a Rental Property?
For a multifamily rental property, a "good" cap rate depends heavily on the market. In a strong, core market, you'll often see cap rates floating between 5.0% and 5.5% in today's environment. If you venture into a growing secondary or tertiary city, you might find deals in the 5.5% to 7% range.
Why the difference? It all comes down to risk. Residential income is usually pretty steady, so investors are comfortable with a lower return in a top-tier market. In a smaller, less proven market, they need a higher potential return to make up for the added uncertainty.
Can a Cap Rate Actually Be Negative?
It can, but it's incredibly rare and usually a massive red flag. A negative cap rate means the property is losing money before you even factor in a mortgage—the operating expenses are higher than the rental income.
The only time an investor would even look at a deal like this is if it's a huge redevelopment play. They're not buying it for the current income; they're betting on a dramatic turnaround or a complete teardown and rebuild. It's a high-stakes, opportunistic game, not a stable investment.
How Do You Use a Cap Rate if a Property Is Empty?
You can't calculate a true cap rate on a vacant building because there's no Net Operating Income. Instead, you have to build a pro-forma analysis.
A pro-forma is essentially an educated guess. You'll project what the potential rent could be by looking at comparable properties in the area, then subtract your estimated operating expenses. This gives you a hypothetical NOI and a "pro-forma cap rate." Just remember, this is a forward-looking estimate, and it carries a lot more risk than a cap rate based on a building with real, rent-paying tenants.
A cap rate is a powerful tool, but it's just a snapshot, not the full movie. It's your first filter for sorting through deals, but it must be followed by a deep dive into the numbers, the property itself, and the market it's in.
A low cap rate isn't always bad, and a high one isn't automatically a home run. The savviest investors learn to read between the lines and understand the story the numbers are telling about risk, location, and true opportunity.
Ready to move beyond the basics and explore institutional-grade real estate investment opportunities? The team at Stiltsville Capital can help you navigate the nuances of the market and build a resilient portfolio. Schedule a confidential call to discuss how our disciplined approach can align with your long-term wealth strategy.
Information presented is for educational purposes only and does not constitute an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy securities. Any offering is made only through definitive offering documents (e.g., private placement memorandum, subscription agreement) and is available solely to investors who meet applicable suitability standards, including “Accredited Investor” status under Rule 501 of Regulation D. Investments in private real estate involve risk, including loss of capital, illiquidity, and no guarantee of distributions. Past performance is not indicative of future results.
Comments